News Release
NEAR RECORD CHAIN RESTAURANT M&A ACTIVITY
March, 2005 – The J. H. Chapman Group, L.L.C.
has just issued the 2004 Chain Restaurant Merger and Acquisition
Census, a comprehensive guide to acquisitions activity in the retail
foodservice industry. This investment banking firm, specializing
in mergers and acquisitions in the food and restaurant industries,
analyzes this information each year and provides a unique perspective
on important trends, according to David L. Epstein, the Chapman
principal who prepares and analyzes the Census.
Merger or acquisition announcements in 2004 increased to 119, a
substantial 53% increase over 2003. Public offering announcements
increased from four to 13, still far short of the record 35 set
in 1996. Two small public companies went private, capitalizing on
the low public valuation of small restaurant chains. Transactions
involving financially troubled chains rose to 24 in 2004 from 19
the previous year, as high debt levels and soft earnings continued
to force many bankruptcy filings.
There is a strong trend among buyers to acquire new growth concepts
as a significant part of their expansion strategies. This diversification
trend led the Census with 33% of the buyers stating it as the reason
for their purchase, followed by 23% listing the quality of the investment
opportunity as the principal reason. The primary seller’s
reason for selling was that their chains no longer met their objectives,
which was cited for 56% of the transactions. Examples of established
chains acquiring new concepts included the Bob Evans Farms, Inc.
purchase of the 81 unit Mimi’s Café, Yum Yum Donuts
purchase of the 200 unit Winchell’s Donut House, and Real
Mex Restaurants purchase of 106 unit Chevy’s.
Notable among the increased activity in 2004 was
the larger number of management buyouts and equity funds acquiring
both troubled and undervalued chains. Equity funds participated
in 17 transactions and management buyouts totaled eight transactions,
both up significantly from the previous year. Examples of equity
fund transactions include Charlesbank Capital Partners’ purchase
of Captain D’s Seafood, Crescent Capital Investments, Inc.’s
purchase of Church’s Chicken, and Roark Capital Corporation’s
purchase of Cinnabon. The management teams of Hacienda Mexican Restaurants,
Jillian’s Entertainment Corporation, and Timber Lodge Steakhouses
were able to become owners of the chains they managed.
Both franchisors and franchisees were also very active acquirers
in 2004. In 25 transactions, almost double the 13 for 2003, franchisees
acquired another franchisee in their own system. Similarly, in 10
transactions, franchisors acquired their own franchisees
Epstein commented that the Summary Census Report,
with graphs and charts, may be obtained from the firm and that he
welcomes questions and discussion. The J.H. Chapman Group is the
food industry’s leading investment banking firm, with offices
in Chicago and Paris, offering a full range of financial advisory
services in the United States and internationally. The Chain Restaurant
Merger and Acquisition Census has been compiled annually since 1987
and lists over 1,850 announced transactions.
The J.H. Chapman Group web site, www.jhchapman.com, contains many
charts and graphs for this and previous Census reports.